Hmmmm – that kid could certainly move, but I take umbrage with the fact that he’s getting a blackbelt. I suppose if it’s based on technical expertise and kata it would be fine, but where’s the whole wisdom of usage and the application to life? I can’t imagine this kid applying lessons learned in class to his first day in kindergarten.
I guess it must be really helpful for balance and co-ordination but difficult to know what a black belt would mean – still he can teach all the younger ones to defend themselves from the older ‘meanies’ in the playground I guess.
Tater – If I were the instructor I’d put the ky-bosh on that over active ki-ya! I’d also probably have to be on sedatives if I ever taught a kids class!
Nicola – My old TKD school had a junior black belt. After you turned 16 you could learn the material that the adults had to learn. I think that’s the reasonable balance. Talent or no talent, I’m just not sure about a 6-year-old being counted on the same scale as adults.
Hi Bob, interesting – I will ask my instructor if they’ve had any over the years, it does seem too weird to have a six year old black belt – for a start there’s no way they’ve done enough pressups in six years of life
May have not been too clear. Prior to 16 junior black belt with a lot of the rougher stuff cut out (i.e. a lot of the violent self-defense techniques).
Upon turning 16 junior black belts could learn the adult material.
5 responses so far ↓
Tater // November 11, 2009 at 4:26 PM
Hmmmm – that kid could certainly move, but I take umbrage with the fact that he’s getting a blackbelt. I suppose if it’s based on technical expertise and kata it would be fine, but where’s the whole wisdom of usage and the application to life? I can’t imagine this kid applying lessons learned in class to his first day in kindergarten.
And Bob – wasn’t that you as the instructor?
NicolaAvery // November 11, 2009 at 5:02 PM
I guess it must be really helpful for balance and co-ordination but difficult to know what a black belt would mean – still he can teach all the younger ones to defend themselves from the older ‘meanies’ in the playground I guess.
Bob Patterson // November 12, 2009 at 5:48 AM
Tater – If I were the instructor I’d put the ky-bosh on that over active ki-ya! I’d also probably have to be on sedatives if I ever taught a kids class!
Nicola – My old TKD school had a junior black belt. After you turned 16 you could learn the material that the adults had to learn. I think that’s the reasonable balance. Talent or no talent, I’m just not sure about a 6-year-old being counted on the same scale as adults.
NicolaAvery // November 12, 2009 at 1:52 PM
Hi Bob, interesting – I will ask my instructor if they’ve had any over the years, it does seem too weird to have a six year old black belt – for a start there’s no way they’ve done enough pressups in six years of life
Bob Patterson // November 12, 2009 at 6:36 PM
Nicola –
May have not been too clear. Prior to 16 junior black belt with a lot of the rougher stuff cut out (i.e. a lot of the violent self-defense techniques).
Upon turning 16 junior black belts could learn the adult material.